Last updated: 20 November 2026
Six senators from both parties wrote to the Treasury Secretary on 18 November, warning that the way the GENIUS Act is being implemented would leave state-regulated stablecoin issuers at a competitive disadvantage against federally chartered ones.
The dispute is narrow, technical, and decides which regulator a stablecoin issuer can realistically choose in the United States. That makes it one of the most consequential open questions in US crypto policy right now and one of the least covered.
Senate Banking Committee Digital Assets Subcommittee Chair Cynthia Lummis and Senator Kirsten Gillibrand led the letter, joined by Senators Angela Alsobrooks, Kevin Cramer, Pete Ricketts, and Mark Warner—three Republicans and three Democrats.
The letter urges Treasury to grant a safe harbor from compliance with section 3 to states that have certified their regulatory regimes as "substantially similar" to federal law while the Stablecoin Certification process runs.
In the senators' words, Treasury's current proposal would offer stablecoin issuers with pending applications to federal regulators a safe harbor as GENIUS Act requirements come into effect, if such a regulator grants a waiver, without a corresponding protection for state issuers.
A federal applicant with a pending application gets breathing room while it is processed. A state-licensed issuer whose state is mid-certification gets none, and faces compliance obligations before the process that would recognise its regime has concluded.
Senator Lummis framed the principle directly: Congress wrote the GENIUS Act to give stablecoin issuers a real choice between a federal and state charter. A choice that only works in one direction is not a choice.
The GENIUS Act, enacted in July 2025, created a dual-path framework. Issuers can seek a federal charter or operate under a state regime that Treasury certifies as substantially similar to the federal standard.
Wyoming's Special Purpose Depository Institution charter is the most developed example of a state framework built specifically for digital asset businesses. States that invested in building these regimes did so on the understanding the federal law would recognize them.
If federal applicants get transitional protection and state applicants do not, issuers rationally choose the federal path regardless of which regime suits them better. The state option then atrophies—not because Congress removed it, but because implementation made it unusable during the transition.
That is the senators' core argument, and it is a process complaint rather than a policy one.
Three observations worth drawing.
With the CLARITY Act having failed a Senate procedural vote in September 2026, market structure legislation is stalled. Stablecoins are the one area where a statute exists—so the live questions have moved from what the law should say to how Treasury and the agencies apply it.
Three senators from each party signed. Crypto policy fights in 2026 have mostly run along party lines, particularly after November's midterms. A charter-parity question does not, because it is about federalism as much as digital assets.
As of publication, Treasury had not publicly responded to the letter. A letter from six senators, including a subcommittee chair, is a strong signal but not a binding instruction, and the Treasury retains discretion over the final rule.
For the wider regulatory picture, see our analysis of where crypto regulation stands across the US, EU and India, which covers why the GENIUS Act's stablecoin framework sits alongside an otherwise unlegislated US market.
GENIUS Act
US federal legislation enacted in July 2025 creating a regulatory framework for payment stablecoins. It does not cover Bitcoin or other non-stablecoin assets.
Payment stablecoin
A token designed to maintain a stable value against a reference currency and used for payments, as defined under the GENIUS Act.
Safe harbor
A provision protecting a party from enforcement while conditions are met, commonly used during transitions to a new regime.
Substantially similar certification
The process by which Treasury recognizes a state regulatory regime as equivalent to the federal standard, allowing issuers to operate under state supervision.
Charter
The license under which a financial institution operates, determining its primary regulator.
SPDI
Special Purpose Depository Institution, Wyoming's charter type designed for digital asset businesses.
Dual-path framework
A structure allowing regulated entities to choose between federal and state supervision.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, regulatory, or investment advice. It describes a letter from members of Congress and a Treasury proposal that had not been finalized at the time of writing. The Treasury had not publicly responded and retains discretion over the final rule. Statements attributed to senators are drawn from the letter and accompanying press release. Nothing here describes how any specific issuer would be treated under either framework. Details are accurate as of 19 November 2026. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on stablecoin licensing or compliance.